Fig.2 - x axis label "y": change to y_cm

Fig2_pip.gifFig2_pim.gif

Fig.4 - still missing data points (pi+, target-like rapidity)
- rapidity window should be shown in y_cm, not y_lab

Fig4_pim.gifFig4_pip_new.gif

- Fig. 7 needs units on the abscissa of the left panel (Ebeam). (Note suppressed zero on the ordinate.)

Fig7_left.gifFig7_right.gif

- Fig.8: I propose to remove the N+N point. It is not a HADES
measurement and should be close to the C+C point. It would raise many
questions which, however, have no impact on the paper content.
If you disagree, leave it as is and we discuss it next week. DONE

Fig8.gif



- Fig.9 Please change the range of the pt axis to 0- 800 MV/c . Also for pi+ open symbols were added. DONE

Fig9_new.gif

-Fig10. I changed y_axis on left side and also for pi+ made open symbols to be consistent with other plots.

Fig10.gif

- Fig.11 c,d: I proposed to have the corresponding pcm distributions
here. If you prefer not to have them, do nothing. I do not see need for this plot in that chapter, since all plots are integrated over rapidity.

- Fig.13: please put <A2> on the ordinate and make pi+ open symbols and
pi- closed symbols as for C+C.

Proper label to that plot :

Mean anisotropy parameter <A_2> as a function of the mean number of participants <A_part>.

Circles represent experimental Au+Au data (open: pi+, closed pi-).

Also shown are earlier HADES results on <A2> average on pi+ and pi- for C+C at 1AGeV (closed triangle) and 2AGeV(open triangle) as well as Ar+KCl at 1.75AGeV (open cross).

Fgi13.gif

Fig 14. Re-size plots and also correct line colors.

Fig14_pip.gifFig14_pim.gif

- Fig.15b: add the first point.

Fig15_pim.gifFgi15_pip.gif

- Fig.16: If not too much work, I like to check wether dn/dpt looks
better. I will re-do this plot in pt, what for mid-rapidity is the same as p_cm. And then it will be in the same as other plots in that chapter where we compare to data.

Fig16_pim.gifFig16_pip.gif

In attachment below you can find also txt file with content of the Table1 which is displayed below.

Table1.gif

*
I Attachment Action Size Date Who CommentSorted ascending
Fgi13.gifgif Fgi13.gif manage 6 K 2019-10-14 - 10:54 GosiaSudol  
Fgi15_pip.gifgif Fgi15_pip.gif manage 17 K 2019-10-14 - 13:23 GosiaSudol  
Fig10.gifgif Fig10.gif manage 11 K 2019-10-17 - 10:32 GosiaSudol  
Fig10.pdfpdf Fig10.pdf manage 18 K 2019-10-17 - 10:32 GosiaSudol  
Fig13.pdfpdf Fig13.pdf manage 13 K 2019-10-14 - 10:54 GosiaSudol  
Fig14_pim.gifgif Fig14_pim.gif manage 15 K 2019-10-14 - 21:14 GosiaSudol  
Fig14_pim.pdfpdf Fig14_pim.pdf manage 21 K 2019-10-14 - 21:14 GosiaSudol  
Fig14_pip.gifgif Fig14_pip.gif manage 14 K 2019-10-14 - 21:14 GosiaSudol  
Fig14_pip.pdfpdf Fig14_pip.pdf manage 20 K 2019-10-14 - 21:16 GosiaSudol  
Fig15_pim.gifgif Fig15_pim.gif manage 17 K 2019-10-14 - 13:23 GosiaSudol  
Fig15_pim.pdfpdf Fig15_pim.pdf manage 19 K 2019-10-14 - 13:23 GosiaSudol  
Fig15_pip.pdfpdf Fig15_pip.pdf manage 19 K 2019-10-14 - 13:23 GosiaSudol  
Fig16_pim.gifgif Fig16_pim.gif manage 10 K 2019-10-20 - 23:02 GosiaSudol  
Fig16_pim.pdfpdf Fig16_pim.pdf manage 20 K 2019-10-20 - 23:02 GosiaSudol  
Fig16_pip.gifgif Fig16_pip.gif manage 10 K 2019-10-20 - 23:03 GosiaSudol  
Fig16_pip.pdfpdf Fig16_pip.pdf manage 20 K 2019-10-20 - 23:02 GosiaSudol  
Fig2_pim.gifgif Fig2_pim.gif manage 18 K 2019-10-14 - 09:31 GosiaSudol  
Fig2_pim.pdfpdf Fig2_pim.pdf manage 511 K 2019-10-14 - 09:30 GosiaSudol  
Fig2_pip.gifgif Fig2_pip.gif manage 18 K 2019-10-14 - 09:31 GosiaSudol  
Fig2_pip.pdfpdf Fig2_pip.pdf manage 511 K 2019-10-14 - 09:29 GosiaSudol  
Fig4_pim.gifgif Fig4_pim.gif manage 17 K 2019-10-14 - 11:51 GosiaSudol  
Fig4_pim.pdfpdf Fig4_pim.pdf manage 34 K 2019-10-14 - 11:52 GosiaSudol  
Fig4_pip.pdfpdf Fig4_pip.pdf manage 33 K 2019-10-14 - 11:52 GosiaSudol  
Fig4_pip_new.gifgif Fig4_pip_new.gif manage 16 K 2019-10-14 - 11:54 GosiaSudol  
Fig7_left.gifgif Fig7_left.gif manage 6 K 2019-10-14 - 10:10 GosiaSudol  
Fig7_left.pdfpdf Fig7_left.pdf manage 17 K 2019-10-14 - 10:10 GosiaSudol  
Fig7_right.gifgif Fig7_right.gif manage 5 K 2019-10-14 - 10:14 GosiaSudol  
Fig7_right.pdfpdf Fig7_right.pdf manage 14 K 2019-10-14 - 10:13 GosiaSudol  
Fig8.gifgif Fig8.gif manage 4 K 2019-10-03 - 17:39 GosiaSudol  
Fig8.pdfpdf Fig8.pdf manage 13 K 2019-10-03 - 17:39 GosiaSudol  
Fig9.pdfpdf Fig9.pdf manage 15 K 2019-10-17 - 09:39 GosiaSudol  
Fig9_new.gifgif Fig9_new.gif manage 4 K 2019-10-17 - 09:40 GosiaSudol  
Table1.gifgif Table1.gif manage 59 K 2019-10-20 - 20:34 GosiaSudol  
Table1.txttxt Table1.txt manage 2 K 2019-10-20 - 20:35 GosiaSudol  
Topic revision: r11 - 2019-10-22, GosiaSudol
Copyright © by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding Foswiki Send feedback | Imprint | Privacy Policy (in German)