Please find below all the collected information about the availability of simulation.

  • SMASH --> Christoph contacted group. Our contact person is Justin Mohs. First results have been sent around. Gosia will run sufficient statistics.
  • PHSD (v4.5)--> Gosia has contacted Elena. Our contact person is Taesoo Song. First results have been sent to us. Files are already at GSI under /luster/hades/user/sudol/phsd_v4_5
  • IQMD --> Yvonne will have a look for the IQMD events with potential. Those events were used for the comparison with HADES data which has been used for kaon paper.
  • GiBUU --> Gosia forgot about that model ;-)
Implementation of the relevant potential for kaons.

GiBUU :

E.g., on Slide 8 of https://gibuu.hepforge.org/trac/chrome/site/tutorial19/Tutorial19_A.pdf we show the potential implementations of a potential.
There are two ways:
1) The Skyrme way: A (non-relativistic, classical) potential given as U_0 is recalculated as a potential V, which is simply a mass shift.
2) The RMF way: A real 4-dim potential U_\mu is provided. --- This works only for very small energies!

Smash :

We still don’t have strangeness potentials in the Smash. Maybe one can still get reasonable results for the Kaons with just all of our strange resonances.

One thing that one can try is to have the threshold for the scattering processes be affected by the potentials. That is still referring to the baryon and symmetry potentials but might influence the strangeness production. One can add Potentials_Affect_Thresholds: True in the Lattice section of the configuration file. While the Kaons themselves are not affected by the potentials, I wouldn’t say they are completely independent of the EOS since they are affected by the dynamics of baryons via scatterings. Note that strange baryons do feel the Skyrme potential in the Smash.
Example of the spectra provided by the models.

SMASH

v1_y.jpgv1_pt.jpg

v2_y.jpgv2_pt.jpg

PHSD

Below are a few lines from the mail of Elena where she explains the present situation of the code

Right now we are finalizing the paper on the "In-medium effects in strangeness production in heavy-ion collisions at (sub-)threshold energies" where we finally(!) realized our big, very complicated and very long project on the implementation of the novel G-matrix for K- from Laura Tolos and Daniel Cabrera and in-medium effects for K+
in the PHSD 4.0+. Here the whole low energy strangeness dynamics in modified accordingly! Thus, we would largely prefer if you compare your data with this code in a future! There will be no need any more to use the HSD1.5 (low energy version of HSD with "old" G-matrix) or old versions of the big PHSD (where G-matrix was not incorporated).
In this study we included the comparison to practically the most of available exp. data on K+, K- , K0, K0s ! (Actually, our results are very close to those from HSD1.5).

v1pt_PHSD.jpgv1y_PHSD.jpgv2pt_PHSD.jpg

-- GosiaSudol - 03 Dec 2020
Topic attachments
I Attachment Action Size Date Who Comment
v1_pt.jpgjpg v1_pt.jpg manage 69.0 K 04 Dec 2020 - 08:59 GosiaSudol  
v1_y.jpgjpg v1_y.jpg manage 62.7 K 04 Dec 2020 - 08:55 GosiaSudol  
v1pt_PHSD.jpgjpg v1pt_PHSD.jpg manage 46.9 K 04 Dec 2020 - 09:05 GosiaSudol  
v1y_PHSD.jpgjpg v1y_PHSD.jpg manage 96.6 K 04 Dec 2020 - 09:06 GosiaSudol  
v2_pt.jpgjpg v2_pt.jpg manage 66.1 K 04 Dec 2020 - 08:59 GosiaSudol  
v2_y.jpgjpg v2_y.jpg manage 96.1 K 04 Dec 2020 - 08:59 GosiaSudol  
v2pt_PHSD.jpgjpg v2pt_PHSD.jpg manage 108.0 K 04 Dec 2020 - 09:05 GosiaSudol  
Topic revision: r4 - 14 Jan 2021, GosiaSudol
 
This site is powered by FoswikiCopyright © by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding Hades Wiki? Send feedback
Imprint (in German)
Privacy Policy (in German)